A published shift is a plan. A time entry is a record of what happened. An approved timesheet is an input to payroll, not proof that payroll accepted it or paid the worker. A workforce stack needs to preserve those differences even when one application displays them together.
This guide is for operations teams choosing scheduling, time and payroll components. It is not payroll advice or a claim that every possible vendor pairing has a ready-made integration.
The smallest useful record map
Availability belongs to the workforce-planning process. Actual time belongs to a reviewed time record. Employee identity and employment details need a personnel source. The payroll product owns the calculated pay run and its exceptions under the applicable local arrangement.
Six current vendor directions illustrate alternatives: Deputy, When I Work and Connecteam for workforce/time work; Personio for personnel context; QuickBooks Payroll and Sage Payroll for market-specific payroll. Do not buy all six simply because they appear in the table.
| Component direction | Candidate | Record to inspect | Handoff to prove |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scheduling and reviewed time | Deputy | Timesheet state and payroll-approved time | Export only the intended approved period |
| Scheduling and attendance | When I Work | Scheduled shift versus recorded time | Review discrepancies before payroll export |
| Time and workforce operations | Connecteam | Reviewed/approved timesheet with controlled reopening | Corrections after approval remain understandable |
| Personnel context | Personio | Employee and preparatory payroll information | Effective employee changes reach the right recipient |
| Payroll | QuickBooks Payroll | Accepted pay-run input in the selected edition | Import exceptions and calculated result |
| Payroll | Sage Payroll | Local-market payroll record | Correct worker/pay-code/period mapping |
This is based on official current documentation. No production connector was installed and no payroll calculation or labour-law compliance result was tested.
Deputy: use the approval state, not the existence of hours
Deputy’s timesheet overview and payroll developer guidance distinguish timesheet states and payroll use. Its integration guidance is useful for deciding how data should move.
Evaluate Deputy when approved worked time is the critical boundary. Demonstrate the difference between a submitted record and a payroll-approved one. Then identify how a reopened timesheet reaches payroll after the original period has already been imported. Exporting a second file without a correction policy can duplicate or contradict the first input.
When I Work: keep planned and recorded time separate
When I Work’s attendance documentation describes combining scheduling with worked-time tracking and reviewing a pay-period summary before export or an integrated payroll route.
This is a useful candidate when shift discrepancies are the operational problem. Ask to demonstrate a scheduled shift with no corresponding time entry and an unscheduled shift that was actually worked. The schedule should provide context, not silently overwrite the actual record or become automatic evidence of approved pay.
Connecteam: inspect approval and reopening
Connecteam’s timesheet documentation describes administrator approval and locking for payroll, with reopening where needed. Its employee-timesheet guide explains the reviewed record.
Investigate it when the workforce process needs visible approval before payroll preparation. Demonstrate who can approve, who can reopen and how the correction is distinguished from the original. Do not equate a location-enabled time clock with independently established attendance accuracy or lawful collection of location data.
Personio: employment information is not another time ledger
Personio’s payroll offering describes preparatory payroll information within a wider HR product. Its role in this component map is personnel context and effective changes, not a claim that the same payroll service is available in every country.
If a scheduling platform already owns worked time, define which Personio fields remain authoritative and avoid two editable copies of the same hours. Demonstrate a worker transfer or effective-dated change without rewriting an already accepted historical period.
QuickBooks Payroll: choose the actual market edition
QuickBooks Payroll is a payroll direction to evaluate for the relevant market and business. Ask which time integration, supported pay types and edition are included in the proposed setup.
The receiving system needs an employee identifier, pay code and period that it understands. Do not treat “export to payroll” as a guarantee of accepted input. Require an exception report and reconcile the accepted hours with the source before considering the handoff complete.
Sage Payroll: country and connector are part of the product
The linked Sage Payroll page concerns the UK offering. Other Sage products and markets are not interchangeable with it.
Evaluate it where that local payroll arrangement fits. Require a demonstration of the actual time import or connector, including a rejected worker or unsupported code. A supplier’s general integration logo is not enough to establish that the required earning types and corrections are supported.
Evaluate one clean period and one correction
Use synthetic workers. Include a part-time availability constraint, a swapped shift, a missing clock-out, an approved absence and a late correction. Trace planned hours, submitted time, approved time and payroll-accepted input separately. The totals need not always match, but every difference should have an owner and reason.
Then try the same export twice. Establish how the proposed integration avoids duplicate input and how an authorised correction is applied. Those are acceptance requirements, not features we assume all products implement identically.
Costs and selection
Compare active-user and employee minimums, time/scheduling modules, payroll country editions, connector fees and reconciliation effort. Start with the component causing the hardest failure rather than replacing the whole stack. Consolidation is useful only if it preserves the approval boundary.
See planned work versus recorded work in an agency stack for the related capacity distinction. Support workforce and QA components also shows why one reporting view should not turn several different records into one authority.
Official sources reviewed 20 October 2026. No live employee tracking, pay run, tax advice or paid inclusion.